Cream or Serum? Relief Sun vs Hyalu-Cica Sun in Dry Heat
The short answer: On protection, it's a tie: both list the same four UV filters and SPF50+ PA++++[1][4][5]. The difference is the base and the feel. Relief Sun is a rice cream the brand pitches at dry, sensitive or normal skin[2][3]; SKIN1004 is a lighter serum the brand calls non-sticky[5]. Reviewers on both report some shine in heat[1][4]. Neither brand claims water resistance[2][5].
Heat check

Two Korean sunscreens come up again and again on Olive Young Global. Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun holds 4.8 out of 5 from 1,377 reviews[1]. SKIN1004’s Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum holds 4.9 out of 5 from 12,027 international reviews[4]. Ratings that close don’t pick a winner.
So here is the question that matters if you live with strong sun and dry heat in Israel or the Gulf: should you reach for a cream or a serum? The short version is that their protection on the label is a tie, and the choice comes down to your skin type and how each one feels once the day heats up.
This piece pulls together the brands’ own pages, the Olive Young listings and public reviews, with every source numbered at the end. I haven’t worn either one myself; it’s a summary of what’s on record.
Do they protect differently?
On the label, no. Both are SPF50+ PA++++[1][5]. More telling, both ingredient lists carry the same four UV filters: Diethylamino Hydroxybenzoyl Hexyl Benzoate, Ethylhexyl Triazone, Methylene Bis-Benzotriazolyl Tetramethylbutylphenol and Diethylhexyl Butamido Triazone[1][4].
Where they split is the base around those filters. Relief Sun lists rice extract right after water[1]. SKIN1004 has no rice; instead it lists centella asiatica extract and hyaluronic acid[4].
Cream or serum: which feels lighter?
Beauty of Joseon describes Relief Sun as creamy yet lightweight, leaving skin looking dewy[2], and recommends it for dry, sensitive or normal skin[3].
SKIN1004 describes its sun serum as ultra lightweight and serum-like, non-sticky, with a dewy finish and no white cast[5]. The brand lists it for combination, sensitive and normal skin[5].
Notice that both brands promise a dewy finish. Neither is sold as matte, so if you want a flat, powdery look, neither one is built for that.
Which one gets shiny in the heat?
Reviewers report some shine on both, and praise for both too.
On Relief Sun, one reviewer with oily skin finds it light and very hydrating, but says that in hot places it makes the face look oily over time[1]. Another, with sensitive skin, calls it very lightweight and perfect for summer[1].
SKIN1004 gets a similar split. One reviewer says it feels noticeably greasy and sets it with translucent powder when wearing it alone[4]. A reviewer with normal skin calls it completely non-sticky[4]. One with oily skin says it’s very lightweight, absorbs quickly enough for makeup, and keeps buying it again[4]. Another says it isn’t as oily as some water gel sunscreens[4]. On white cast, one reviewer still saw a white layer, especially around facial hair[4].
These are a handful of voices, not a percentage of users. If your skin is oily and shine is the main worry, the lighter Relief Sun Aqua-fresh is covered in our sunscreens that don’t melt roundup.
Do they hold up to sweat?
Neither brand claims water or sweat resistance[2][5]. Beauty of Joseon’s own Relief Sun page says to use a water-resistant sunscreen if you’re swimming or sweating, to reapply at least every 2 hours, and to reapply sooner after sweating, swimming or towel drying[2]. SKIN1004’s page only says to apply it evenly as the last step of skincare on sun-exposed areas[5].
Heat matters off the face too. Beauty of Joseon advises keeping sunscreen somewhere cool and shaded and not leaving it in a car in summer[6].
One more note for sensitive skin: one SKIN1004 reviewer says it irritated their skin and caused breakouts[4], so patch-test a small area first. For more on how Relief Sun behaves in the heat, see our Relief Sun hot-weather review.
Skip it if your skin turns shiny by midday in the heat: reviewers report shine on both, and one SKIN1004 reviewer sets it with powder[1][4]. Skip both for swimming or heavy sweat; neither brand claims water resistance[2][5].
Where to buy, by country
Some of these links earn Sunwise a commission.
Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun: Rice + Probiotics (50mL)

| Country | Where | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Israel | Olive Young Global | US$14.99checked |
SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum (50mL x2 twin pack)

| Country | Where | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Israel | Olive Young Global | US$21.50checked |
Prices move. Check the total at checkout before you pay.
Sources
- [1]Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun : Rice + Probiotics 50mL, Olive Young Global (read )
- [2]Relief Sun: Rice + Probiotics, Beauty of Joseon (read )
- [3]Mastering Relief Sun and Aqua-Fresh, Beauty of Joseon (read )
- [4]SKIN1004 Madagascar Centella Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum 50mL*2ea (Twin pack), Olive Young Global (read )
- [5]Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum SPF50+ PA++++, SKIN1004 (read )
- [6]FAQ: Products, Beauty of Joseon (read )
Same problem, other reads
- Mineral vs Chemical Sunscreen: Which for Strong Sun?
Mineral or chemical sunscreen? What the AAD, Cleveland Clinic and the FDA say about how each works, safety, sensitive skin and hot, sweaty days.
- Your First Skincare Routine in Hot Weather
A three-step routine from the AAD: cleanse, moisturise, protect. Sources differ on SPF 15 or 30. We found nothing that changes the routine for heat.
- Removing Sunscreen: Is One Cleanser Enough?
Does one wash remove sunscreen? Cleveland Clinic says double cleansing helps with waterproof sunscreen but is usually not necessary. Plus AAD wash steps.